Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"The Pear" by Jane Hirshfield is a powerful meditation on aging, mental health, and the tenacity of life, both human and natural. The poem begins with the image of a lone pear swaying "past leaves, past reason" on a tree in November, an unlikely survivor in an unsympathetic season. This image finds its human counterpart in the speaker's friend in a nursing home, who, despite suffering from delusions and the impositions of institutional life, clings to his existence with a mix of dread and eloquence.

The opening scene sets the stage for a deep exploration of vulnerability. In November, fruit trees are usually barren; leaves have fallen, and winter is fast approaching. The pear becomes a symbol of resilience and of things past their prime but still hanging on. It's a metaphor enriched by the second stanza, where the friend in the nursing home is introduced. The friend's delusions-that he's been "chased" by well-read literary figures like Thoreau, Coleridge, and Beaumarchais-show that even in his mental fragility, he remains intellectually vibrant. "Delusion too, it seems, can be well read," the speaker observes, injecting a note of dark humor but also highlighting the complex nature of human decay.

The poem's structure is as careful as its content, relying on straightforward narrative to tell its complex story. Hirshfield employs a free-verse form but adheres to a measured pace, allowing each line to weigh heavily, much like the subjects she tackles. This measured pace draws the reader's attention to every nuance, from the "old fineness" that "hangs on for dear life" in the friend's character to the rigidity of institutional rules where "the angles matter."

A recurrent theme in Hirshfield's work is the symbiosis between humans and the natural world, and this poem is no exception. The pear and the old man are bound by the common thread of tenacity against the odds. "Life is dear to him yet," the speaker notes, capturing the ambivalence of wanting to continue despite hardship. He remains acutely aware of his life's challenges, describing his mind as "a small ship under the wake of a large," yet still finds it important enough to keep holding on.

The poem concludes with a poignant view of the relentless nature of life and decay, "The argument goes on, he cannot outrun it." In other words, the internal and external struggles are endless, and no amount of intellectualization can change the outcome. "Dawnlight to dawnlight, I look: it is still there," the poem closes, turning our attention back to the pear. The lingering image suggests a quiet admiration for both the pear and the friend, still existing despite their compromised states.

In "The Pear," Hirshfield offers a nuanced understanding of the complexities of life and death, doing so with empathy and intellectual depth. The poem serves as a reminder of our vulnerabilities but also celebrates the resilience that allows us, and nature, to persist even when odds are stacked against us.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...