Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In "Four Poems About Jamaica: 4. Kingston," William Matthews explores the limitations of photography in capturing the essence and realities of a place, specifically Kingston, Jamaica. The poem contrasts the idealized images often presented in photographs with the gritty and challenging realities of life in the city. Through this exploration, Matthews delves into themes of perception, representation, and the human condition.

The poem begins with the assertion that "No photograph does justice, etc.," a common sentiment that photographs cannot fully capture the truth or essence of their subjects. However, the poem quickly shifts focus, questioning the purpose of a photograph: "but what does a photograph care / for justice? It wants to be clear." This line suggests that the primary concern of a photograph is clarity and perhaps aesthetic appeal, rather than a truthful or just representation of reality. The comparison to an angel, which "need not mean, / but be," further emphasizes this point. An angel's duty is to exist and fulfill its role, not necessarily to convey meaning or intention, much like a photograph's role is to present an image without needing to encapsulate the full truth.

The poem then takes a closer look at the subject matter of these photographs: "No angels here. Hovels seen from far / enough away they look picturesque." This juxtaposition highlights the disparity between the aesthetic appeal of distant, idealized images and the harsh reality of poverty. From afar, what might seem quaint or picturesque is, upon closer inspection, a depiction of hardship and struggle. The "blatant blue sky so cool in pictures / is gritty with heat," revealing a disconnect between the serene, cool colors of photographs and the oppressive heat and discomfort experienced in reality.

Matthews continues to peel back the layers of illusion: "The long day stings. / We squint at the lens." The use of "stings" conveys the discomfort and harshness of the environment, while "squint at the lens" suggests a difficulty in seeing clearly, both literally and metaphorically. The lines in the faces of those being photographed are described as "engraved by the acids / of muscle-habits, not by tears." This description emphasizes that the marks of hardship are not necessarily from visible emotional expressions like crying, but from the physical toll of enduring daily life.

The poem also touches on the challenge of understanding and empathy: "Sympathy we have to learn." This line suggests that sympathy is not an innate quality but something that must be developed, often through exposure to others' experiences. The poem provides a striking example: "Here's / a family of three living in a dead car." This image starkly contrasts with the picturesque views and emphasizes the severe poverty and desperation that can exist behind the facade of beauty or simplicity.

The guidebooks, which "warned us away / from this," represent a curated, sanitized version of travel that often omits the less pleasant realities. However, the speaker and their companions choose to confront these realities, described as coming "ungainly, spreading / our understandings of sorrow like wet wings." The metaphor of "wet wings" suggests an awkward, uncomfortable, and perhaps ineffectual attempt to grasp and comprehend the sorrow and hardship observed. The final lines, "We turn and turn, but everywhere is here, / a blurred circle of wing scuffs," encapsulate the sense of disorientation and the difficulty of escaping the pervasive reality of poverty and suffering. The "blurred circle" suggests a lack of clear understanding or resolution, as the observers continue to struggle with their perceptions and the stark realities they face.

"Kingston" challenges the notion that visual representations, like photographs, can fully convey the complexities and harsh truths of a place. Matthews explores the tension between aesthetic representation and reality, and the poem critiques the limitations of external perspectives in capturing the lived experiences of those in difficult circumstances. Through vivid imagery and a reflective tone, the poem invites readers to consider the deeper truths that lie beyond the surface of images and to grapple with the complexities of empathy and understanding.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...