Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"I Could Not Tell" by Sharon Olds explores the themes of memory, perception, and the subconscious actions that we sometimes take in moments of stress or irritation. The poem recounts an incident where the speaker, distracted and preoccupied, jumps off a moving bus while holding her child, only to later reflect on the complexities of that moment and her subsequent realization of the risks involved.

The poem begins with the speaker confessing her inability to fully grasp or remember the details of the incident as it happened. She starts by admitting, "I could not tell I had jumped off that bus, that bus in motion, with my child in my arms, because I did not know it." This line sets the tone for the poem, revealing the dissonance between the speaker's actions and her conscious awareness. The speaker believed a different version of the events—that she had simply fallen, or that the bus had unexpectedly started moving while she was mid-step.

As the poem progresses, Olds delves into the emotions and physical sensations experienced during the incident. The speaker recalls the frustration of missing her stop, which may have contributed to her sudden, impulsive decision to step out "into the air." This frustration, coupled with the child's innocent obliviousness—described as "the clear child gazing about her in the air"—paints a vivid picture of a chaotic yet somehow surreal moment. The speaker's landing is abrupt and painful, as she "plunged to one knee on the street, scraped it, twisted it." The bus driver reacts quickly, stopping the vehicle and rushing out, while the child's reaction is surprisingly lighthearted, even playful, as she laughs and says, "Do it again."

The juxtaposition of the child's amusement with the gravity of the situation highlights the differing perceptions of the event. The child, unaware of the danger, finds the experience entertaining, while the speaker, with the benefit of hindsight, recognizes the severity and recklessness of her actions. This recognition is encapsulated in the speaker's admission that she has "never done it again," emphasizing the lesson learned from the experience. The phrase "I have been very careful" underscores the speaker's shift towards caution and heightened awareness of the potential consequences of her actions.

Olds continues to reflect on the incident with a tone of self-awareness and introspection. The speaker describes watching herself from a detached perspective, referring to herself in the third person as "that nice young mother who lightly leapt off the moving vehicle onto the stopped street." This distancing language suggests a sense of disbelief and a need to rationalize or make sense of her past behavior. The imagery of "her life in her hands, her life’s life in her hands" poignantly conveys the dual responsibility the speaker feels—not only for her own life but also for the life of her child. The repetition of "life" emphasizes the preciousness and vulnerability of both lives involved.

"I Could Not Tell" captures a moment of parental fallibility and the complexities of human behavior under stress. Sharon Olds uses the incident as a vehicle to explore how we sometimes act without full awareness, driven by emotions or subconscious impulses, and how such moments can lead to profound realizations and changes in behavior. The poem's reflective and confessional tone allows readers to connect with the speaker's experience, offering a meditation on the responsibilities of parenthood and the ways in which we navigate the challenges and uncertainties of life. Through vivid imagery and thoughtful introspection, Olds presents a nuanced portrayal of a moment that is both mundane and deeply significant, reminding us of the fragility and preciousness of life.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...