Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Crazy Horse Speaks: 1" by Sherman Alexie offers a poignant take on the historical and spiritual landscape of indigenous suffering, particularly as it pertains to the Lakota leader Crazy Horse. The poem packs a powerful message into just a few lines, confronting historical erasure, indigenous identity, and spiritual reckoning.

Alexie opens the poem with a shocking discovery: "3,000 skeletons of my cousins / in a vault of the Mormon Church." This line unearths the unsettling history of colonialism and the treatment of indigenous remains, while also critiquing institutions, like the church, that have been complicit in the erasure or commodification of indigenous cultures. The specific mention of the "Mormon Church" adds a layer of religious complexity, hinting at the broader issue of spiritual colonialism.

The silence surrounding this mass grave is "so great" that it warrants containment, a "four walls" built around it. This silence could represent the neglect or suppression of indigenous history, but its enormity could also suggest a heavy, haunting presence that demands attention.

The speaker then proceeds to give the silence a name: "Custer," after General George Armstrong Custer, known for his role in the Indian Wars. This is a profound act. By naming the silence after an agent of colonial violence, the speaker attempts to define the undefinable, to give shape to the shapeless horror of history. Naming is a form of control; it's a way to contextualize and confront what has been systematically overlooked or intentionally hidden.

However, in a surreal twist, Custer appears in a dream and forgives the speaker's sins. This moment offers a compelling inversion of the power dynamics. Custer, the colonizer, now stands in a position to offer forgiveness, perhaps hinting at the internalized guilt or conflict that many indigenous people feel as survivors of a long history of colonial trauma.

The dream sequence can be viewed as a moment of reclaiming agency and autonomy, even if it is shrouded in complexity and ambiguity. It can also be seen as a commentary on the insufficiency of forgiveness in addressing the profound injustices suffered by indigenous peoples. After all, the forgiveness of sins is a deeply personal, even selfish, act that does nothing to redress the communal and generational traumas inflicted upon the indigenous population.

Alexie's poem, then, serves as an evocative metaphor for the ongoing struggle for recognition, reconciliation, and healing. It succinctly captures the intertwined complexities of historical trauma, religious institutions, and personal guilt. It tells a story that is both specific to Crazy Horse and representative of larger indigenous experiences. This dual focus makes the poem an impactful critique of historical erasure and a haunting call for understanding and reparation.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...