Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

William Carlos Williams’s "Smell" is a striking meditation on human sensibility, desire, and the often unseemly nature of curiosity. By personifying his own nose as an eager yet indiscriminate participant in the world, Williams explores themes of sensory experience, moral judgment, and the unrelenting drive to engage with life in all its beauty and decay.

The opening lines, "Oh strong-ridged and deeply hollowed / nose of mine! what will you not be smelling?" establish the nose as the poem?s protagonist, simultaneously celebrated and admonished. The descriptors "strong-ridged" and "deeply hollowed" evoke an almost sculptural quality, suggesting a physicality that is both imposing and vulnerable. The question that follows is laced with both humor and exasperation, setting the tone for the poem’s exploration of sensory indulgence.

The nose becomes a metaphor for human curiosity and engagement, described as "always indiscriminate, always unashamed." These traits, while potentially admirable in their openness, also position the nose as tactless and intrusive. By aligning himself with the nose—"What tactless asses we are, you and I, boney nose"—the speaker acknowledges his own complicity in this unreserved exploration of the world. The use of "asses" underscores the self-deprecating tone, highlighting the absurdity of their shared persistence.

The poem takes a visceral turn with the description of "the souring flowers of the bedraggled / poplars: a festering pulp on the wet earth / beneath them." This image vividly captures the sensory assault of decay, emphasizing the nose’s capacity—and compulsion—to engage with even the most unpleasant aspects of the world. The phrase "festering pulp" evokes a tactile, almost grotesque sensation, while the "wet earth" situates the scene in a damp, springtime setting that is both fertile and decaying. The juxtaposition of flowers, symbols of beauty, with their rot highlights the dual nature of sensory experience, where attraction and revulsion coexist.

The lines "With what deep thirst / we quicken our desires / to that rank odor of a passing springtime!" delve into the paradoxical allure of the unpleasant. The word "thirst" conveys an almost primal need, suggesting that even the "rank odor" has a magnetic pull. The phrase "passing springtime" introduces a note of transience, linking the decay to the ephemeral nature of life itself. The speaker’s "quicken[ing]" of desire for such an odor reflects the human tendency to engage deeply with all facets of existence, even those that might repel or discomfort.

The speaker’s rhetorical questions, "Can you not be decent? Can you not reserve your ardors / for something less unlovely?" reflect an internal conflict between sensory indulgence and social decorum. The plea for "decency" reveals a tension between the nose’s unfiltered curiosity and societal expectations of refinement. This conflict is further underscored by the concern for external judgment: "What girl will care / for us, do you think, if we continue in these ways?" The shift to romantic implications adds another layer to the poem, tying the nose’s indiscretions to broader questions of desirability and acceptance.

The closing lines—"Must you taste everything? Must you know everything? / Must you have a part in everything?"—escalate the critique while underscoring the insatiable nature of curiosity. The repetition of "Must you" emphasizes the relentless drive to experience and understand, while the verbs "taste," "know," and "have a part in" suggest a holistic engagement with the world. These questions, though directed at the nose, resonate as a broader critique of human nature, capturing the unquenchable thirst for experience that defines both our strengths and weaknesses.

Structurally, the poem’s free verse format allows for a conversational tone, enhancing the sense of introspection and dialogue. The enjambment between lines mirrors the restless flow of thought, reflecting the speaker’s oscillation between indulgence and restraint. The absence of a strict rhyme scheme or meter emphasizes the organic, unfiltered nature of the subject matter.

Thematically, "Smell" examines the complexities of sensory engagement and the tension between instinct and judgment. By personifying the nose, Williams creates a vehicle for exploring the paradox of human curiosity: its capacity to draw us into both beauty and repulsion, and its role in shaping our connection to the world. The poem also touches on societal expectations, questioning the limits imposed on desire and the consequences of unrestrained exploration.

"Smell" is a vivid and thought-provoking reflection on the sensory and moral dimensions of human experience. Through its humor, vivid imagery, and introspective tone, the poem captures the richness and complexity of living fully engaged with the world, even when that engagement challenges conventional notions of propriety. Williams’s ability to transform a seemingly mundane subject into a meditation on the human condition underscores his poetic brilliance.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...