Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Dilemma" by Richard Aldington is a reflective and subtly profound poem that explores the choice between seeking new experiences and contemplating those already had. It contrasts the allure of adventure and discovery with the quiet introspection of memory and familiarity. Aldington, known for his Imagist poetry, which emphasizes clarity and directness of expression, uses a blend of vivid imagery and contemplative tone to convey this theme.

The poem begins with a question posed by the speaker's companion: whether to continue adventuring in pursuit of new experiences or to sit quietly and reflect on past adventures. This question encapsulates a fundamental human dilemma between the desire for novelty and the comfort of the familiar.

Rather than answering in words, the speaker, who professes to be "sick of words and talk," chooses to respond by drawing the companion to a window to observe the twilight scene. This silent response suggests that some questions are better answered through experience and observation rather than verbal explanation.

The description of the evening scene is rich with sensory detail: the orange glow of the setting sun, the young moon with a star, the swifts flying over the roofs, and the bats gliding through the square. These natural elements symbolize the beauty and tranquility of the familiar world. The scene also includes human elements: people talking and strolling, a peasant's cart with a candle-lit paper shade, and the sound of a mandoline. This blend of natural and human details creates a tapestry of ordinary yet poignant beauty, suggesting the richness to be found in everyday experiences.

The speaker's silent gesture to this scene serves as an indirect answer to the companion's question. It implies that beauty, wonder, and meaning can be found in the simple observation of life as it unfolds, without the need for constant new adventures or experiences.

In the end, the companion's response to this silent answer is uncertain, as they eventually speak of other things. This unresolved ending reflects the ambiguity of the original question and suggests that the answer may be different for each individual. The speaker acknowledges this uncertainty, admitting, "But I do not know any other silence to give you."

In summary, "Dilemma" by Richard Aldington is a contemplative poem that uses vivid imagery and a thoughtful narrative to explore the tension between the desire for new experiences and the appreciation of familiar ones. The poem's nuanced portrayal of this common human conflict and its open-ended conclusion invite the reader to consider their own response to this universal dilemma.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...