|
|
Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained | |||
"That the Science of Cartography Is Limited" by Eavan Boland is a poignant meditation on the limitations of maps and, by extension, the limitations of human attempts to capture and represent reality. Through the exploration of a historical and deeply personal landscape, Boland critiques the inadequacy of maps to convey the full depth of human experience, particularly the suffering and historical trauma associated with the Irish Famine of the mid-19th century. The poem opens with a declaration of intent: to prove that maps, for all their detail and precision, cannot capture the essence of a place—its smells, its atmosphere, its emotional resonances. Boland uses the example of a forest, noting that its representation on a map cannot convey "the fragrance of balsam, the gloom of cypresses." The narrative then shifts to a personal memory shared between the speaker and a loved one. They drive to Connacht and stumble upon a "famine road," a road built by starving Irish people during the Great Famine as a form of relief work provided by the government or Relief Committees. These roads, often leading nowhere and built as a means to justify providing aid to the starving, become a powerful symbol of suffering and desperation. Boland skillfully weaves together the personal and the historical, grounding the abstract critique of cartography in the tangible, emotional reality of the famine road. The speaker's reflection on the road, "Where they died, there the road ended / and ends still," underscores the permanence of loss and the way in which certain histories are inscribed upon the landscape, even if they are absent from official maps. The act of looking at a map, for the speaker, is not an exercise in appreciating the cartographer's skill or the transformation of the spherical earth into a flat representation. Instead, it is a means of confronting the elisions and silences of the map, particularly the failure to mark the spaces of historical trauma like the famine roads. The speaker seeks to remind herself that the map's neat lines and labels cannot account for the profound human experiences of hunger, loss, and endurance that have shaped the landscape. The poem concludes with a reflection on the limitations of the cartographic line to capture the complexity of the woodland that both "cries hunger" and "finds no horizon." This line, which fails to appear on the map, symbolizes the broader failure of maps—and, by implication, any attempt to neatly categorize and contain human experience within defined boundaries—to fully encompass the depth and nuance of reality. "That the Science of Cartography Is Limited" is a powerful exploration of the intersection between geography, history, and memory. Boland's poem challenges readers to consider the ways in which official narratives and representations, such as maps, can obscure as much as they reveal, and how personal and collective memories can serve as counter-maps that trace the contours of loss and resilience etched into the landscape.
| Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!Other Poems of Interest...THE VEGETABLES by JAMES MCMICHAEL THE CELLAR by LAURE-ANNE BOSSELAAR CONCERNING NECESSITY by HAYDEN CARRUTH MISHIPASINGHAN, LUMCHIPAMUDANA, ETC by ALBERT GOLDBARTH ROAST POTATOES by DENISE LEVERTOV THIS SPUD'S FOR YOU by WILLIAM MATTHEWS SEEING A BASKET OF LOBELIA THE COLOR OF A BATHROBE by MOLLY PEACOCK THE DUCHESS POTATOES by DIANE WAKOSKI ELEGY FOR AN ENEMY by STEPHEN VINCENT BENET EPIGRAM ON MY WEDDING DAY: TO PENELOPE by GEORGE GORDON BYRON |
| |