Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In Randall Jarrell's "Cinderella," the fairy tale receives a somber makeover, one that melds traditional whimsy with brutal reality. Far removed from the idyllic world of glass slippers and fairy godmothers we've come to associate with Cinderella, Jarrell's narrative takes us into the protagonist's fraught psychological terrain.

The poem begins with Cinderella and her imaginary godmother sitting by the fire, a scene evocative of warmth and solace. This interaction appears rooted in comfort and maternal wisdom, as if to defy the unforgiving world outside. However, the illusion shatters as the godmother softly suggests "What men want…" but leaves the thought unfinished, letting the ambiguity sink into the reader's mind. This incomplete thought foreshadows the expectations and disillusionments that Cinderella will experience as she navigates a world designed by men's desires.

The godmother and Cinderella share "a cup of tea," a domestic symbol that gains a cynical edge when contrasted against the "reality" of Cinderella's life. Her glass slippers and the prince's champagne toast present an idealized reality that belies the stark realism lurking beneath. Her "silk feet" may fit into glass slippers, but it's a torturous transformation that demands she conform to an artificial image of perfection.

This disconnect between perception and reality is further complicated when Cinderella looks at herself in her bridal veil. Her reflection reveals the underlying struggles that mar her picturesque life-she "wished it all a widow's coal-black weeds." In this moment, the reader confronts the sheer tragedy of Cinderella's life, her yearning to escape the claustrophobic perfection that has been foisted upon her. Instead of aspiring for a fairy-tale ending, she longs for widowhood, a condition traditionally associated with sorrow but perhaps for her, a form of freedom.

As a "sullen wife and reluctant mother," Cinderella's fantasy has corroded into a dispassionate reality. The fire she once found comforting now serves as a space for her to ruminate over her sorrow, a cyclical agony projected onto future generations. The last stanzas of the poem evoke an eternal damnation for Cinderella, her fate inextricably linked to the stifling roles that society and men have imposed on her.

The cultural context of the poem amplifies its impact. Written in a modern setting, it challenges the simplistic notion of 'happily ever after,' questioning the roles that women are confined to and the choices that are ostensibly made for them. Jarrell's Cinderella becomes a compelling figure of subversion against not only the institution of marriage but also against the fairy-tale narrative itself, which has for generations presented skewed gender norms and societal expectations.

In summary, Randall Jarrell's "Cinderella" is an unsettling interrogation of a well-known fairy tale, invoking a complex network of themes ranging from the male gaze to societal constraints on women. Through the artful juxtaposition of the fantastic and the real, the poem lays bare the corrosive effects of living within a narrative that one neither chose nor desires, leaving both Cinderella and the reader to question the very nature of 'happily ever after.'

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...