Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Susan Wheeler’s “The Scar” is a haunting meditation on identity, displacement, and the inexorable passage of time. The poem's narrative lens is introspective, drawing readers into the psychological terrain of a speaker who has returned to a place or state of being, only to find themselves irrevocably altered. Wheeler employs stark imagery and a fragmented structure to explore themes of estrangement and recognition, making the poem resonate with a sense of quiet despair and self-revelation.

The opening lines set the tone of disorientation and alienation: “So long gone had I been / that when I returned / I did not know me.” The speaker’s return, whether to a physical location or an internal sense of self, is marked by an unsettling unfamiliarity. This disconnection introduces the central tension of the poem—the difficulty of reconciling past and present selves. The speaker is both the observer and the observed, fragmented by time and experience.

The narrative shifts to an encounter that deepens the speaker’s estrangement. The act of calling out “warily, through the trees” suggests a tentative, almost fearful approach, as if the speaker anticipates rejection or further alienation. The comparison to a “thief” or “ground mole” amplifies the speaker’s sense of shame and insignificance, presenting them as an intruder in their own life. This self-perception as a “worm on end” underscores the speaker’s vulnerability and diminished sense of self-worth.

The figure in the doorway—possibly a family member or a symbolic representation of the speaker’s past—introduces an external gaze that contrasts with the speaker’s internal turmoil. The description of her “whiten[ing] in the doorway” conveys both shock and recognition, as though the act of seeing the speaker reveals something unspoken or repressed. The question, “Linda, is that you?” carries an implicit yearning for affirmation, a desire to bridge the gap between past and present identities.

The poem’s emotional climax occurs in the recognition of arrival: “That was when I knew I had arrived.” However, this arrival is not triumphant but deeply ambivalent. The “last step” is described as “impassably long,” suggesting that the act of returning or reconciling with oneself is fraught with difficulty. The scar, implied by the title but never directly addressed in the poem, becomes a metaphor for the lasting mark of past wounds—both physical and emotional. It signifies the permanence of transformation, a reminder that the speaker will “always / be twinned.”

The final lines capture the speaker’s longing “to not know returning.” This desire to escape the cyclical nature of departure and return underscores the impossibility of reclaiming a previous wholeness. The scar, whether literal or metaphorical, is a testament to the inevitability of change and the enduring struggle to reconcile the fragments of identity.

“The Scar” is a powerful exploration of loss, recognition, and the complexities of selfhood. Wheeler’s spare yet evocative language creates a mood of quiet intensity, drawing readers into the speaker’s internal conflict. The poem’s universality lies in its portrayal of the human experience of being irrevocably marked by time and circumstance, while its intimacy invites readers to reflect on their own scars—both visible and invisible. Through its layered imagery and poignant narrative, the poem leaves an indelible impression, much like the scar it evokes.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...