Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In "Hughie at the Inn or, Advice from a Tapster" by Elinor Wylie, the speaker, a tapster (or innkeeper), offers a satirical yet insightful commentary on the nature of heroism, fate, and fortune. Through a series of exaggerated and ironic scenarios, the speaker mocks the traditional notions of valor, triumph, and gallant suffering, replacing them with a cynical view of life’s unpredictability and the wisdom of caution over reckless bravery.

The poem opens with a rhetorical question: “Is it not fine to fling against loaded dice / Yet to win once or twice?” This immediately sets the tone for the poem, suggesting that there is something absurd about engaging in a game rigged by fate and still occasionally finding success. The imagery of “loaded dice” conveys the idea that the odds are stacked against the player, yet the occasional win does little to prove skill or merit; it’s more a result of chance than any true triumph. This sense of the randomness of life runs throughout the poem, setting up a critique of heroic or idealized notions of struggle and success.

The subsequent lines further explore this theme of superficial victories. The speaker presents a series of scenarios where individuals, despite facing tremendous odds, experience outcomes that seem both absurd and ultimately unworthy of admiration. “To bear a rusty sword without an edge / Yet wound the thief in the hedge” is a mock-heroic image, highlighting the ridiculousness of winning a battle with a weapon that is not only ineffective but also seemingly destined for failure. Similarly, the lines “To be unhorsed, and drown in horrid muck, / And in at the death, by luck” further emphasize the randomness and irony of life, where even the most miserable situations might end in unexpected fortune.

The poem continues with more ironic examples: a person “to meet a masked assassin in a cape, / And kill him, and escape,” or “to have the usurers all your fortune take, / And a bare living make.” These scenarios are depicted as equally absurd—victories achieved by chance or through no real effort, or enduring hardship with little gain. The figure of the “usurer,” someone who profits off the misfortunes of others, contrasts sharply with the idea of earning a living through personal labor, which the speaker deems less glamorous but more grounded in reality.

The following stanzas present more exaggerated examples of hardship and survival, such as being caught in a bad marriage or “cast into a prison damp and vile, / And break bars with a blunt file.” The heroism in these examples seems dubious at best, as the speaker suggests that what is often celebrated as courage or fortitude is simply a consequence of being forced into difficult circumstances. Similarly, “To be cut down from gallows while you breathe / And live, by the skin of your teeth” invokes a near-death experience that, rather than reflecting true heroism, underscores the randomness of life and death, where survival often has more to do with luck than valor.

At the poem’s climax, the speaker questions the nature of “heroic” endeavors, asking, “Is it not fine, worthy of Titans or gods, / To challenge such heavy odds?” This rhetorical question implies that these “heroic” actions—while perhaps impressive in their scale—are not truly praiseworthy but instead reflect the chaos of life and the dubious nature of fortune. The speaker's tone shifts here, suggesting that what might seem like bold defiance or heroism is really just a manifestation of "cruel chance gone mad."

The speaker concludes by offering a more grounded perspective on life. Rather than seeking out reckless adventure or heroism, he advises caution: “Season your ale, now these long nights draw in, / With thought to save your skin: / Be provident, and pray for cowardice / And the loaded pair of dice.” The speaker suggests that prudence and foresight—perhaps even cowardice—are the more valuable virtues, as opposed to chasing after fleeting glory or engaging in dangerous pursuits. The “loaded pair of dice” here represents the unpredictable nature of life, suggesting that one’s best strategy is to prepare for the worst and hope for the best, rather than naively pursuing risky or heroic endeavors that often end in failure or misfortune.

In "Hughie at the Inn or, Advice from a Tapster," Wylie uses humor and irony to critique the traditional romanticization of heroism, offering a more skeptical and pragmatic view of life’s struggles. Through exaggerated and absurd examples of courage and misfortune, the speaker argues that many so-called heroic acts are mere chance or bad luck dressed up as valor. The poem challenges the glorification of suffering and struggle, advocating instead for caution, prudence, and the acceptance of life’s unpredictable nature.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...