Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Lines in Praise of Professor Blackie" by William McGonagall is an elegy, a form of poetry dedicated to commemorating the life of someone who has passed away. In this case, the poem mourns the death of Professor John Stuart Blackie, a Scottish scholar, language expert, and a man of letters. McGonagall, known for his distinctive and often criticized style, paints a touching tribute to Blackie, detailing his many virtues, accomplishments, and widespread respect among the people.

Provenance:

William McGonagall, often dubbed as "the worst poet in English language," was a Scottish weaver, actor, and poet known for his unique style. His poetry, frequently marked by awkward rhymes, forced rhythms, and weak imagery, has gained a somewhat ironic cult following. Nevertheless, "Lines in Praise of Professor Blackie" represents a heartfelt tribute to a fellow Scot and respected intellectual, demonstrating McGonagall's genuine respect for Blackie.

Context:

The poem was written in the late 19th century, shortly after Blackie's death in 1895. The Victorian era, in which both McGonagall and Blackie lived, was marked by an emphasis on morality, propriety, and public duty. These themes come across strongly in McGonagall's portrayal of Blackie as a man of charity, wisdom, and Christian piety.

Theme Analysis:

Death and Loss: The poem primarily explores themes of death and loss. McGonagall mourns the death of Blackie, speaking of how much he will be missed and how irreplaceable he is.

Virtue and Morality: The poem extols Blackie's virtuous and moral character. It describes him as a Christian, charitable, kind-hearted man who showed compassion for others and was not prone to vanity or pride.

Accomplishments and Legacy: The poem also pays tribute to Blackie's accomplishments and his enduring legacy. It refers to his extensive travels, his love for Scotland, his storytelling prowess, and his singing abilities.

Poetic Devices:

Rhyme: McGonagall uses an AABB rhyme scheme throughout the poem, which is typical of his style and serves to enhance the poem's rhythmic flow.

Repetition: The poet employs repetition to emphasize the depth of Blackie's virtues and the profound sense of loss felt by his passing.

Imagery: While McGonagall's imagery is generally regarded as weak, he does attempt to visualize Blackie's character and the scene of his death.

Hyperbole: McGonagall uses hyperbole to highlight Blackie's virtues and accomplishments, as seen in lines like "Worthy of a monument, and your name written thereon in letters of gold."

Conclusion:

"Lines in Praise of Professor Blackie" by William McGonagall provides an insight into the poet's capacity for genuine emotion and respect for a fellow intellectual. Despite McGonagall's often-mocked poetic style, this piece serves as a heartfelt tribute to a revered figure, capturing themes of death, virtue, and legacy in a simple yet direct manner. Through his personal reflection and simple language, McGonagall ensures that his admiration for Blackie shines through.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...