Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Who Is He?" by Dora Sigerson Shorter is a poignant reflection on the theme of death, especially a death that occurs during the time of life and renewal. Structured in four stanzas, each exploring a different perspective on death, the poem addresses the struggle of dying, the embodiment of hope, the indifference of others, and the profound sorrow of those who care. The imagery and repetition employed in the poem work together to create a solemn and contemplative mood.

Themes

Struggle of Death: The opening stanza presents the agony of death in a season of life and joy. The juxtaposition of dying with the vibrant imagery of June, birds, and bees accentuates the unnaturalness of death during a time of renewal.

Hope and Desolation: Hope is personified and depicted lying low, perhaps even defeated. This anthropomorphism gives a tangible form to an abstract concept, making the loss of hope more striking.

Indifference and Loss: The lack of mourners in the third stanza represents society's indifference to death and suffering. This bleak portrayal heightens the tragedy of the death.

Grief and Suffering: The final stanza introduces the image of youth and love weeping, signifying a deeply personal and emotional connection to the deceased. The raw emotion here emphasizes the heaviness of grief.

Analysis

The Hardness of Death: Death's struggle is highlighted by placing it against the backdrop of June, a month typically associated with life and growth. This contrast adds a layer of complexity, suggesting that dying during a time of vibrancy is particularly challenging.

Personification of Hope: By giving human characteristics to hope, the poet makes the concept more tangible and immediate. The imagery of hounds and the stag further alludes to a hunt, where hope itself seems to be the prey.

Indifference and Humanity's Cruelty: The absence of mourners, and the question "Is there never a one to weep?" signifies the apathy of society towards individual suffering. This cruel indifference contrasts sharply with the genuine grief expressed in the final stanza.

Youth, Love, and Sorrow: The weeping of youth and love symbolizes innocence and purity, qualities that make the suffering more poignant. The statement "Better were death than woe" reflects a deep despair and a longing for release from pain.

Structure and Style

The poem consists of four stanzas, with each exploring a different facet of death. The repetition of certain words, like "hard," "die," "lie," and "weep," creates a rhythm that underscores the poem's themes. This rhythmic quality, along with the use of enjambment, adds a mournful tone to the verses.

Historical and Cultural Context

The depiction of death, hope, and sorrow in "Who Is He?" can be seen as reflecting a broader human condition, one that transcends specific historical or cultural contexts. The poem's themes resonate with universal human experiences of loss, despair, and the struggle to find meaning in suffering.

Conclusion

"Who Is He?" by Dora Sigerson Shorter is a moving exploration of death and its various dimensions, ranging from the physical struggle to die to the emotional impact on those left behind. Through powerful imagery, rhythmic repetition, and a deep sense of empathy, Shorter crafts a poem that speaks to the human condition in all its complexity and tragedy.

By addressing both the individual experience and the societal response to death, the poet reveals a profound understanding of life's fragility and the importance of compassion and empathy. The poem serves as a reminder of our shared humanity and the need to recognize and honor the suffering of others.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...