Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Five and Dime," by Allison Joseph, vividly portrays the complex interplay of race, class, and childhood in the setting of a neighborhood discount store. The poem immerses the reader in a vivid, sensory-laden environment, juxtaposing the vibrant life of the community with the hostility of the store manager and the degrading experiences faced by its patrons, particularly the narrator. Through precise imagery and a deeply personal perspective, Joseph captures the tension between exclusion and resilience, weaving a narrative that is as much about systemic marginalization as it is about the defiance and agency of a young girl.

The opening lines set the stage with the name "McCrory’s," grounding the poem in a specific cultural and economic context: the ubiquitous five-and-dime stores of mid-century America, often associated with affordability and community. Yet, Joseph undercuts this idealized image immediately, describing the store’s "junky merchandise" under "circling dust motes and buzzing fluorescent lights." These details evoke a sense of neglect and decay, creating a stark contrast to the vibrancy of the neighborhood outside, where "Spanish floated in and out of doorways" and pizza shops offered "spicy beef patties" and "fizzy Jamaican ginger beer." This juxtaposition highlights the divide between the store’s inhospitable atmosphere and the diverse, thriving culture of its surrounding community.

At the heart of the poem is the store manager, a figure of hostility and resentment. His "pockmarked face" and "lower lip twisted in spite" serve as physical manifestations of his disdain for the store’s patrons, whom he views with suspicion and contempt. His "hefty, lurching gait" and "snarl" reinforce his menacing presence, as does his frustration with the "tan and brown bodies" that fill his store. The manager’s overt racialized disdain underscores a broader commentary on how marginalized communities are often treated with suspicion and hostility in spaces meant to serve them.

The narrator’s perspective offers a sharp counterpoint to the manager’s animosity. A young girl exploring the aisles, she finds joy and curiosity in the mundane objects around her: "jars of hair grease and straightening combs," "lipsticks too bright or too brown," and "giant bottles of watery shampoo or bubble bath." Her tactile engagement with the store?s offerings—picking things up, smelling, and touching—conveys a sense of wonder and a desire for agency in a world that often denies her choices. Yet, this innocent curiosity is met with suspicion. The manager assumes she is a thief, projecting onto her the very criminality he despises, reflecting a deep-seated bias that infantilizes and criminalizes Black and brown youth.

The confrontation between the manager and the narrator is the poem?s emotional crescendo. The manager’s physical aggression—grabbing her shoulder and shaking her—escalates the tension, transforming a routine visit into an act of humiliation and violence. His demand to know "where [her] mother was" reveals an assumption of neglect, further othering her and erasing her autonomy. The poem’s irony lies in the store’s positioning as a "friendly discount store" and "place for values," slogans that sharply contrast with the hostile reality the narrator experiences.

Joseph?s use of sensory detail and specific cultural markers deepens the reader?s connection to the narrative. The sticky fingers, the scent of bubble gum shampoo, and the feel of "wrinkled corduroy pants and no-name jeans" evoke the tactile and olfactory richness of childhood, even as these details are overshadowed by the sting of injustice. The narrator’s resilience is palpable in her defiant touching of "whatever [she] wanted to touch," a small act of rebellion against the store’s unwelcoming atmosphere and the manager’s oppressive gaze.

The poem ends with the narrator being forcibly removed from the store, a moment of physical and emotional expulsion that underscores the dehumanizing effects of systemic prejudice. Yet, her presence in the poem—the detailed recounting of her experience, her ability to articulate the injustice—is itself an act of resistance. By reclaiming her narrative, Joseph allows the narrator to assert her humanity in the face of a system that seeks to deny it.

"Five and Dime" is a powerful exploration of the intersection of childhood innocence, racial prejudice, and economic marginalization. Through its vivid imagery and poignant narrative, the poem lays bare the indignities faced by those who are systematically othered while celebrating the quiet defiance and resilience of a young girl navigating a hostile world.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...