Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Roden Berkeley Wriothesley Noel’s "Where a Dim Sea-Presence Broodeth in Solemn Sullen State," a selection from “Thalatta,” presents a vivid and haunting depiction of the sea, not as a peaceful or nurturing force but as a grim, almost malevolent presence. Through the poem’s stark, evocative imagery, Noel explores themes of destruction, despair, and the vast, impersonal power of nature. The poem portrays the ocean as a relentless and unforgiving force that both captivates and terrifies, evoking a sense of awe in its readers.

From the very beginning, Noel establishes the sea as a "dim Sea-Presence" that "broodeth in solemn sullen state." The word "broodeth" suggests a deep, contemplative stillness, yet one filled with a sense of foreboding. This sea-presence is not tranquil; rather, it exudes a dark, moody power. The phrase "solemn sullen state" conveys an atmosphere of gravity and melancholy, as though the sea holds within it a vast, unfathomable sadness. By describing the sea as a "presence," Noel personifies it, turning it into a living, conscious entity, one that looms over the poem with an ominous and almost godlike authority.

The speaker describes a place where "no mortal breath dare whisper," highlighting the sea’s alien nature. This is a realm where human life has no place, a world entirely dominated by the relentless, chaotic power of the ocean. The "hollow sounding surges" and "melancholy dirges" of the waves reinforce the idea that the sea is both a physical and emotional force, one that expresses its own form of mourning or lament. These "melancholy dirges" suggest the sea’s role as a witness to countless tragedies, its waves singing a mournful song for the lives it has claimed over the centuries.

Noel’s description of the waves as "a welter of wild waters" that "rave in echoing cave" conveys their uncontrollable and chaotic nature. The alliteration of "wild waters" and the verb "rave" give the sense that the sea is filled with untamed energy, crashing against the shore with a fury that knows no bounds. The waves, we are told, once "rent" the cave "long ago," making it a lair for "grim Despair." This image of the sea creating a home for despair further underscores its association with destruction and death. The cave, a place of darkness and isolation, becomes a physical manifestation of the sorrow and hopelessness that the sea brings to those who encounter it.

The waves are depicted as rolling "prodigious boulders" to and fro with "Atlantean shoulders." This image of the sea as a powerful, almost mythic force likens it to the titanic strength of Atlas, the figure from Greek mythology who bore the weight of the world on his shoulders. The comparison reinforces the idea that the sea is beyond human comprehension or control, a force of nature that shapes the world around it with immense, unyielding power. The waves'; ability to round boulders "like pebbles" speaks to their incredible strength, which can reduce even the largest stones to smooth, small shapes over time.

The poem’s imagery grows darker as the speaker describes the "foamy serpents" that "wallow upon the wilderness" near the "palace-portals" of the sea’s court. These serpents, symbolic of danger and treachery, evoke the deadly nature of the sea, which conceals its lethal potential beneath a surface that may appear calm or enticing. The "wilderness" that surrounds the sea is "grey and cold afar," reinforcing the desolation and lifelessness of the landscape. This is not a place of life or growth, but one of cold, unforgiving nature.

As the poem progresses, Noel shifts his focus to the human cost of the sea’s power. Among the "tumbled boulders" and in front of the "giant cave," we find the "crunched and shattered timbers" of "mighty ships" and the "limbs of some" who perished in the violent froth of the waves. These remnants of ships and human bodies serve as grim reminders of the sea’s ability to destroy anything in its path, reducing even the strongest ships and sailors to wreckage and bones. The mention of the sailors who "craving one more kiss of loving lips" died in the waves introduces a poignant element of human tragedy. These are not nameless, faceless victims—they are people who longed for life and love, only to be swallowed by the sea.

The final image of the poem is particularly haunting, as Noel describes the "glossy weed" that "may dally with their coral-crusted bones." The seaweed, indifferent to the human remains beneath it, plays and drifts among the bones, further emphasizing the idea that the sea is an impersonal force, one that takes life without remorse or recognition. The image of "coral-crusted bones" suggests that, over time, even the remains of the dead become part of the sea, encrusted with coral and transformed into something unrecognizable.

In "Where a Dim Sea-Presence Broodeth in Solemn Sullen State," Noel captures the dual nature of the sea as both awe-inspiring and terrifying. The sea’s immense power is portrayed as both a creative and destructive force, capable of shaping the landscape and claiming lives with equal ease. Through vivid, often unsettling imagery, Noel evokes the timeless and impersonal nature of the ocean, where human life is fleeting and fragile in the face of its relentless, unstoppable energy. The poem serves as a meditation on the power of nature and the inevitable destruction that comes with time, making it a powerful reflection on both the beauty and the terror of the sea.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...