Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Wallace Stevens’ "Six Discordant Songs: Contrary Theses (2)" is a reflective exploration of impermanence, abstraction, and the tension between lived experience and conceptual thought. Through rich imagery and a meditative tone, the poem juxtaposes the fleeting details of a fall afternoon with the speaker’s search for an enduring, universal truth. It reflects Stevens’ preoccupation with the interplay between the concrete and the abstract, the personal and the cosmic.

The poem opens with an evocative scene: "One chemical afternoon in mid-autumn, / When the grand mechanics of earth and sky were near." The phrase "chemical afternoon" suggests a scientific or elemental quality to the day, emphasizing its transience and physicality. The "grand mechanics" highlight the underlying systems of nature, from the turning of the seasons to the cosmic order. These opening lines establish a backdrop of both immediacy and universality, setting the stage for the speaker’s reflections.

Amid this larger framework, the poem focuses on intimate, everyday details: "He walked with his year-old boy on his shoulder. / The sun shone and the dog barked and the baby slept." This snapshot of domestic life contrasts with the vastness of the "earth and sky," grounding the poem in human experience. The repetition of "the leaves, even of the locust, the green locust" underscores the speaker’s attention to the natural world, while the yellowing leaves serve as a marker of seasonal change and the inevitability of decay.

The speaker’s internal struggle becomes apparent as he "looked for a final refuge / From the bombastic intimations of winter / And the martyrs a la mode." Winter, with its "bombastic intimations," symbolizes the harsh realities and existential threats that disrupt the harmony of the present moment. The "martyrs a la mode" inject a note of skepticism, critiquing fashionable or performative forms of suffering. These lines reveal a desire to escape the weight of cultural and natural cycles, seeking solace in something enduring and abstract.

The phrase "an abstract, of which the sun, the dog, the boy / Were contours" introduces the central theme of the poem: the relationship between tangible experiences and the larger, ineffable truths they suggest. The speaker’s walk becomes a meditation on how the specific and the universal intersect. The description of "Cold... chilling the wide-moving swans" and "leaves... falling like notes from a piano" highlights the beauty and fragility of the moment, as well as its connection to deeper, elusive meanings.

The abstract itself is described as fleeting: "The abstract was suddenly there and gone again." This momentary glimpse suggests that the universal truths the speaker seeks are transient, revealed only briefly before disappearing. The ordinary activity of "negroes... playing football in the park" serves as a grounding counterpoint, reminding the speaker of life’s vibrant immediacy even as he contemplates its broader implications.

The final lines return to the motif of abstraction and its relationship to the physical world: "The abstract that he saw, like the locust-leaves, plainly: / The premiss from which all things were conclusions." Here, the falling locust leaves symbolize the cyclical and impermanent nature of life, while also pointing to an underlying order or "premiss" that connects all things. The "noble, Alexandrine verve" suggests a poetic grandeur or intellectual vigor, yet it is immediately balanced by the mundane: "The flies / And the bees still sought the chrysanthemums’ odor." This juxtaposition reaffirms the tension between the sublime and the ordinary, the abstract and the concrete.

Structurally, the poem’s free verse form mirrors its thematic exploration of fluidity and impermanence. The lack of rhyme or strict meter allows Stevens to move seamlessly between detailed descriptions and philosophical reflections, creating a meditative rhythm that mirrors the speaker’s contemplative walk. The recurring imagery of leaves, light, and seasonal change ties the poem’s observations together, while the shifts in tone—from serene to critical, from grand to intimate—reflect the complexity of the speaker’s inner journey.

"Six Discordant Songs: Contrary Theses (2)" captures Stevens’ fascination with the interplay of the ephemeral and the eternal. Through its vivid imagery and philosophical depth, the poem invites readers to consider how moments of ordinary beauty and personal experience can point toward larger, abstract truths. At the same time, it acknowledges the difficulty of fully grasping these truths, emphasizing their fleeting and elusive nature. By blending the specific and the universal, Stevens creates a richly layered meditation on the nature of perception, existence, and the search for meaning in a world that is both beautiful and impermanent.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...