Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In "Signs: 3," Derek Walcott turns his gaze to the haunting remnants of Europe's twentieth-century atrocities, specifically the Holocaust. Through a masterful use of imagery and historical allusion, the poem evokes a chilling atmosphere of loss, silence, and complicity. The poem grapples with the weight of history, memory, and the persistent echoes of trauma that linger in the architecture, streets, and culture of the Old World. Walcott’s use of signs and symbols throughout the poem illustrates how the horrors of the past continue to shape the present, even as modern life attempts to move forward.

The poem opens with a description of cobblestones "huddle[d] like shorn heads," immediately invoking a sense of human vulnerability and violation. The comparison of the cobbles to "shorn heads" conjures images of those who were dehumanized during the Holocaust, their identities erased as they were rounded up and led to concentration camps. The architectural elements of the city—"gables leaning over a street to whisper"—suggest that the very buildings themselves are witnesses to unspeakable events. The "walls are scraped of signs condemning David's star," referring to the forced marking of Jewish homes and businesses with the Star of David during the Nazi occupation. The removal of these signs does not erase the history they signify; rather, it leaves behind a void, a silence that speaks volumes.

Walcott masterfully evokes the terror of the Nazi regime with the line, "Gray faces are screening themselves (like the moon drawing thin curtains to the tramp of jackboots)." The "gray faces" could be those of survivors, the complicit, or those who now inhabit these spaces, all trying to shield themselves from the memories of past horrors. The image of "jackboots" marching and "shattered glass rain[ing] diamonds on the pavement" is a stark reference to "Kristallnacht", the Night of Broken Glass, when Jewish homes, businesses, and synagogues were attacked, and windows were smashed en masse. The glass, described as "raining diamonds," is a cruel juxtaposition of beauty and violence, further amplifying the sense of horror.

The poem moves from the historical to the present with a reflection on the silence that has overtaken these streets: "A remorseless silence took the old tenants away." This line mourns the absence of those who were forcibly removed—whether deported to concentration camps or killed. The silence is "remorseless," emphasizing the absence of justice or resolution. The "signs the streets dare not pronounce" refer to the unspoken but ever-present reminders of this trauma, which are too painful or too politically fraught to be fully acknowledged. The streets themselves seem burdened with the weight of history, their "meaning" lost or suppressed.

Walcott introduces the theme of "repetitions," noting that the fog clouds the cobbles, echoing the "ethnic cleaning" of past atrocities. The word "repetitions" suggests that history is cyclical, with similar horrors continuing to unfold in different times and places. The "ethnic cleaning" connects the Holocaust with modern instances of genocide and systemic violence, implying that the lessons of the past have not been learned. The streets, once the site of Nazi terror, now bear witness to new forms of suffering.

As the poem progresses, Walcott turns his attention to the aestheticization of history through the lens of film and media. "Arc-lamps come on, and with them, the movie-setting," he writes, describing how the past has been turned into a spectacle, something to be consumed and re-enacted. The "swastika shadows" and "gas-lamps" evoke the eerie atmosphere of occupied Europe, but they are now part of a "movie-setting," an artifice that distances the viewer from the true horror of the events. The streets are described as an "interminable sentence," a metaphor for the unending nature of historical trauma and the way it continues to haunt the present. Even the "soot-eyed extras" standing in a breadline are waiting for their moment in the re-enactment, reduced to roles in a performance of history.

Walcott uses the metaphor of a "sequel" to suggest that history, like a film, is constantly revisited, reinterpreted, and repackaged. Yet, the orchestration of this "sequel" is marked by "conscience," as the poem subtly critiques the commodification of trauma and the way it is often simplified or sanitized for modern audiences. The "Expressionist corners of the Old Town" evoke the angular, distorted forms of Expressionist art, a style associated with emotional intensity and a response to the alienation of modernity. Walcott seems to suggest that our understanding of history is similarly distorted, shaped by the medium through which it is presented.

In the final lines, the poem returns to the "accurate paraphernalia" of the past—symbols and objects that remain as reminders of what occurred. The "repeated signs of a sequel" evoke the cyclical nature of history, the idea that the same events or patterns of violence repeat themselves across time. The "cantor's echo" introduces a religious element, as the cantor’s voice calls out in a liturgical tradition, but even this voice is reduced to an "echo," distant and faint. The ancient Jewish tradition that "forbade graven images"—a reference to the prohibition against idolatry in the Torah—now "makes indifferent sense." This suggests a loss of meaning, as the profound spiritual and cultural symbols of the past have become detached from their original significance in the face of modern violence and historical repetition.

In "Signs: 3," Derek Walcott reflects on the lasting impact of the Holocaust and the way in which history is both remembered and reinterpreted. Through powerful, vivid imagery, Walcott evokes the terror of the Nazi era while critiquing the way that history is often commodified or reduced to spectacle. The poem grapples with the weight of memory, the silence of complicity, and the repetition of historical violence, ultimately suggesting that the past continues to shape the present in ways that are often unseen or unacknowledged. Walcott’s intricate weaving of symbols, history, and aesthetic critique makes "Signs: 3" a poignant meditation on the enduring scars of collective trauma.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...